Taking Action

Get Answers Start Your Divorce Stop Your Divorce Divorce Forms Online Support

Divorce Tools

Online Divorce Online Negotiation Custody Tracker Custody Evaluation QDRO Preparation Divorce Calendar SEE ALL

Info Categories

Contemplating Divorce Children & Divorce Divorce, Dollars & Debt Divorce Laws Divorce Process Divorce Negotiation SEE ALL

State Resources

California Florida Illinois New York Texas SEE ALL

More Information

Articles Checklists Research Center Cases of Interest Dictionary Encyclopedia Encyclopedia (pop-up) Blogs

For Professionals

Generate Clients Free Network Page Submit Articles Sign In

The Divorce Encyclopedia
Fraud


Term Definition Fraud - a material and intentional misrepresentation, by omission or commission, to induce someone to surrender something of value.
Application in Divorce Fraud includes a number of actions, both direct and indirect, by which one part improperly exploits another. It includes acts deemed "bad," which are malfeasant; omissions, which are nonfeasant, and misrepresentations that induce someone of act with reliance but to his or her detriment.

Fraud means acting in bad faith, but all actions of bad faith are not fraudulent.

In divorce actions, most fraud claims stem from an inducement to marry, separation agreements and evidence at trial. In order to upset an earlier judgment, the fraud must be material, and the victim must prove substantial harm that could not be detected with reasonable care. Fraud and misrepresentation can be grounds for an annulment.

Fraud can be perpetrated when one party fails to tell another the "whole truth."

In divorce, fraud usually might also be connected with the hiding of assets and forms of economic misconduct and also be accompanied by perjury and lying.

When one spouse discovers the other has hidden marital assets or lied about the value, the victim has a number of remedies. If the divorce is not final, he or she can raise the issue in the divorce case.

If the division has been made, the victim may in some cases turn to the agreement itself. Increasingly separation agreements and even divorce decrees contain a residuary clause that allocates nondisclosed assets. This can exercised with a motion to enforce.

Absent the residuary clause, a party may move to upset the agreement by a motion alleging fraud, and beyond that, a growing number of courts now recognize that the victim spouse may bring an action on the common law grounds of fraud. This is a tort, and generally the elements of fraud for a marital tort are 1) misrepresentation, 2) a fraudulent utterance, 3) an intention by the maker to induce a party to act, 4) reasonable reliance by the recipient upon the misrepresentation, and 5) damage to the recipient.

A party may not allege fraud merely because he or she later becomes unhappy with the property settlement, and settlement, with few exceptions, should be considered set in stone.

In general, the spouse who prevails must convince the court that "equities weigh in his or her favor," and outcome is far from clear because "equities are not usually crystal clear." To prove fraud, the moving spouse must prove that he or she relied on the misrepresentation, and courts consider due diligence exercised by the moving party. Thus, misrepresentation of asset values on the part of one spouse or nondisclosure of assets does not necessarily constitute fraud, and the burden of proof falls on the party alleging fraud and must be clear and convincing.

Allegations of fraud and duress may turn on questions of what is called extrinsic versus intrinsic fraud. Extrinsic fraud is fraud perpetrated against a court; intrinsic fraud is fraud committed against a party. For example, in a 1994 California appeals case, a former wife proved extrinsic fraud in a case where her husband persuaded her to sign what was described as an "Appearance, Stipulation and Waiver" that divided property and allowed him to divorce her without notification. He then lived with her for 10 years before she discovered the fraud!

Some jurisdictions allow judgments to be attacked for intrinsic fraud for a much shorter time after the ruling than they do in cases of extrinsic fraud. Many states have adopted rules modeled on Rule 60(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, which requires that a motion be filed within one year of the judgment.

Allegations of fraud may also involve questions of duress, which normally includes a threat or some form of coercion. Yet even a death by an estranged husband failed to persuade a Missouri appellate court that duress has been established because the formerly divorced woman’s "prior experience with property settlement negotiations" made the court believe "she was fully aware of her property rights and the effects of signing the separation agreement." (In fairness, the case may have also turned on a problem common in many divorce cases, that is, he said-she said, without any independent evidence).

See also Duress.

Add the Divorce Encyclopedia to Your Website!


The Research Center

Give Our Research Center a Try. Gain access to the same research material that lawyers often use to establish and win divorce cases. This material consists of legal journal articles and case explanation/analysis documents on a wide range of topics. If you think your situation is unique, your answers will most likely be here. In order to gain access to this area, you must establish an account, but you can search the documents before deciding.


The Divorce Source Difference

Since February 1st, 1997 (when we initially launched Divorcesource.com) we have helped millions of people contemplating or experiencing divorce. The reason we have been able to reach so many people is because we have made it a priority to listen to our customers. We have built a trust by listening and delivering what the customer needs, rather than what we think they want. This is the Divorce Source difference.


Social

Easily Connect With a Lawyer or Mediator
Have Divorce Professionals from Your Area Contact You!
Enter Your Zip Code:

Custody Scheduling and Tracking

Easily Connect With a Lawyer or Mediator
Have Divorce Professionals from Your Area Contact You!
Enter Your Zip Code:

 

Start Your Divorce File for Divorce

 

Settle Your Divorce Negotiate Your Divorce

 

Track Child Custody Track Custody & Visitation

Negotiate Your Divorce Online

Limited Offer Women's Rights Manual For Divorce
Cover Price: $55.95
Your Price: $29.95
You Save: $26.00

"The Absolute Best Investment in Your Divorce"

Men's Rights Manual For Divorce
Cover Price: $55.95
Your Price: $29.95
You Save: $26.00

"Uncover Your Options and Unleash Solutions"